the amazing creations in bamboo, tinsel and
paper of mythical creatures and figures,
enjoying all the fun of a mediaeval English
fair.
It needs a Chaucer to do
justice to 'these festivals and pilgrimages.
As in his day, most of the pilgrimage is
sheer holiday and most of the pilgrims want
nothing more, but there is a deeper side, as
there was in the shrines and aisles of
Canterbury.
To see this deeper side you
must be humble enough to shed your shoes and stockings
and climb bare-foot the well-worn steps to the shrines
that cluster so higgledy-piggledy round the base of the
pagoda. There you will find the more devout, mostly
women, as in the Christian churches of the West,
kneeling with prayerful hands before an image of the
Buddha, asking maybe a husband or child or maybe
something more spiritual ; or perhaps a tired old man,
conscious that life is nearly over and that it is high
time to pay serious attention to deeper things, telling
his beads and finding refuge from a difficult,
perplexing world in the three unfailing sources of
refuge, the Buddha, the Law and the Church. If you have
an understanding Burmese friend with you he may
translate some of the prayers spoken aloud, and you will
discover a wide charity in the prayers for all living
beings divine and human, and in the generous sharing of
the merit gained by the worshipper's prayer. And next
door to this quiet shrine you will find a jostling
crowd, lighting candles and offering flowers or
gold-leaf at the shrine of one of the eight planets, for
every n knows from the initial letter of his name
on what day of the week he was born, and does what he
can to secure good luck from the stars. As ever,
religion and superstition, closely intertwined. Once
again the visitor will be puzzled and find it difficult
to evaluate the part which Buddhism plays in the lives
of the people.
The Buddha
The Burmese or Burma
people are almost
entirely Buddhists. They are followers of the Buddha, a
great Indian religious |
|

Buddha
Head |
teacher
who lived in the sixth century before Christ. His clan
name was Gaudama, and he was the son of a small rajah in
Central India. He and his family were Hindus by
religion, brought up in the religion of the Upanishads
and of older religious literature and tradition. From an
early age Gaudama had been troubled by the amount of
suffering he saw around him, suffering connected with
birth, disease, old age, death, running the whole span
of man's life. Possibly too he was struck by the
contrast between the extravagance and luxury of his
court life and the squalor and poverty of the poor who
lived in the mud huts around. That grinding poverty of
the common people of India is still today the thing that
strikes and appalls the visitor from another country or
the thinking Indian who loves his fellow men.
This
consciousness of universal suffering so worked in the
mind of the sensitive young yuvaraj that finally he left
his father's court, his wife and new-born child, to try
and discover for men a way of release from suffering. To
him suffering was the primary evil and he felt an
irresistible urge to discover its cause and so show men
how to escape from it. His search led him to sit under
the leading gurus or teachers of his day, to study the
various philosophical schools, to undergo every form of
asceticism. But in none of these did he find any answer
to his problem, and despairing of outside help he
decided to seek his goal by himself and within himself.
At last understanding came to him, as he sat in
meditation under the Bo tree at Buddha-gaya. From that
|
| time
on we know him no longer as Gaudama, but as the
Buddha, the Enlightened One, the One who knows. |
The Four Noble Truths
He summed up his discovery for
later disciples in the Four Noble Truths about Suffering.
The first was one that he had already recognized, that
suffering is general and co-terminus with life. Suffering is
involved in birth, sickness, decay, death, sorrow, in
separation from the people and things we like, in having to
live with people and things we dislike, in not getting what
we want : all is suffering.
The second is the origin of suffering. Suffering springs
from desire, craving, lust, attachment to people and things.
The third is the truth about the ceasing of suffering :
namely, to escape from suffering crush out desire and
craving, break all bonds of attachment.
And the fourth is the way to crush desire, by following the
eight-fold path of right belief, right aim, right speech,
right action, right livelihood, right effort, right
mindfulness, right contemplation.
Now there is no doubt that this is noble teaching of deep
insight into human nature, and if put into practice would
produce noble character both personal and national. It may
not rise to the heights of Christ's view of suffering as the
raw material for spiritual maturity and victory, nor is it
so far reaching in its discrimination as Christ's insistence
that evil is the primary thing to be avoided. rather than
suffering. But it does get down to the root of much human
suffering, and it is emphatically practical in its advice
how to eliminate desire.
In practice many Buddhists have held that the-Buddha
insisted on the elimination of all desire, good as well as
bad, and this has tended to make them passive, free from
that selfless burning desire to get rid of social evils and
to serve their fellow men. This is not seen in the Buddha,
for after he had become enlightened, after he had completely
repudiated selfishness and desire in himself and had thus
attained Nirvana (Nirvana), he deliberately chose to live
on in the world for the salvation of men.
|

U Min
Dhonesae Pagoda Sagaing |
Karma and Merit
We must not forget that the
Buddha was a Hindu, a Hindu reformer certainly, who perhaps
without intending it founded a new religion. Among the
doctrines taken over from Hinduism by Buddhists none were
more-strongly held than those of karma and transmigration.
The Buddha's emphasis on cause and effect was clearly-seen
in the four truths of suffering enunciated by him, and this
has been elaborated into a dominant principle in Buddhism.
Present suffering is thought to be caused by the demerit or
guilt inherited from a former existence, while present
happiness is the reward of virtue in former lives. Thus
one's present state is determined by the law of karma, and
nothing can prevent the relentless working out of this
|
|
law. In practice this tends to
produce an attitude of fatalism, which discourages Buddhists
from making any whole-hearted attempt to overcome misfortune
or to indulge in philanthropic work to any great extent. One
who is a leper or blind or a cripple is so because of his
karma ; it is both mistaken and useless to interfere. The
accumulation of guilt has to be worked off until the last
farthing is paid, and then there will be no rebirth in the
world, but the attainment of Nirvana. To Buddhists the Christian doctrine
of forgiveness seems not only impossible but immoral.
|

Kaung-hmu-daw
Pagoda Sagaing |
The accumulation of merit
becomes a chief concern to the Buddhist, and in
the good deeds most productive of merit are those
connected with the support of the Buddhist religion.
Thus to build a monastery or pagoda or to feed the monks
is looked upon as much more efficacious than building a
hospital or feeding the hungry, with the result that
monasteries and pagodas are everywhere, but hospitals
almost only where government has put up the money or
Western missions have been at work.
So the doctrine
of karma discourages a courageous attack on
social evils or personal misfortunes—it is
definitely nobler in the Buddhist mind to
suffer the slings and arrows of outrageous
fortune,
|
| than
to take arms against a sea of troubles and by
opposing end them. |
|
But let it be said that in recent years there has been
an increase in works of mercy and philanthropy, though
the balance is still heavily weighted in favor of the
more institutional forms of merit. And all through,
the accumulation of merit is far too often the main
motive of giving, together -with its advertisement on
foundation stones or dedicatory
brass plates. But there, in the West, the number of
people who feature in subscription lists as 'Anonymous'
is equally small.
Yet it needs to be said that the doctrine of karma looks
forward as well as backward, although this is not often
emphasised. For as much as the past determines the
present, the present is going to determine the future.
This should be an incentive to the Buddhist to a life of
effort and virtue, so that having bravely overcome the
handicap from past existences he may lay a foundation
for his next cycle of life.
It might be thought that a belief in karma and a
recurring series of lives in the world as animal or man
indicated a belief in personality. But this is not so.
It is not the same personal entity or soul that is
carried on from one life to the other, but only the
accumulation of demerit, the character that has been
built up ; just as a new candle is lit from one that is
about to go out, so the karma is handed on. There is no
self, for human existence is thought of as being
determined by the five khandhas or groups of body,
feeling, perception, mental activity, and consciousness
; when these are combined together in operation life
|

Buddha Statue
Mandalay |
exists, when they disintegrate death takes place. This
lack of belief in a continuing personality in man, of a
controller of the five khandhas, of a being personally
responsible for the past and the fashioner of the
future, has not been an incentive to the development of
personality or for attempting great achievements. Yet
it does witness to the idea that the attainment of ideal
character is a matter of long and painful effort, for
which one short span of life is not enough.
Even the
Buddha himself lived through five hundred and fifty
lives (and there is a jakata or birth story for each
one) before he attained to Buddha hood. Indeed one of
the early symbols of Buddhism was that of a wheel,
hinting of the long journey to be traveled and the
recurring lives to be lived before the perfection of
Nirvana can be attained. Mrs. Rhys Davids speaks of man
as a wayfarer on the long road of becoming, undergoing
change and growth until the process of becoming is
complete and man reaches the ideal and so enters his
Nirvana.
But the Burmas or n
are seldom
logical, even in his religion, and his
superstitious belief in the ghosts of the dead
suggests that the doctrine of no-personality
does not command very deep obedience. For when a
member of the household dies the other members
of the family will not go to sleep while the
corpse is in the house but sit up with neighbors
and friends playing games and talking all
through the night. Often a notice will be placed
on the grave warning the dead person not to
return. |
|
Even in the more sophisticated circles of government
service, when a man dies his name is published in
the official gazette and permission is given for him
to retire from government service. Once after taking
the funeral service of a Christian student who had
died, I was approached by his Buddhist
school-fellows and asked to put a notice on the
grave saying : `Maung Kyaw, take notice that your
name has this day been struck off the school
register, so please do not return.' But this may be
merely due to the survival of pre-Buddhist animist
ideas. A similar thought is seen in the reluctance
of ns to wake a sleeping person suddenly, lest
his spirit or 'butterfly' should fail to return in
time and so cause his death |
|
Is There a God?
Just as
Buddhism in Burma or , Ceylon and
Thailand or Siam denies the
existence of soul or self in man, so it denies the
existence of a Supreme Being, an Ideal Personality,
an Eternal God, and it claims that this was the
teaching of the Buddha. He certainly did not give
any definite teaching about God, nor did lie define
him as a person. But this evidence is purely
negative and at the most can only be cited as
showing that the Buddha was an agnostic. It is
possible that he did not regard the existence of God
as provable one way or the other, and so did not
regard it as of sufficient practical importance to
spend much time on it. He was certainly questioned
by
disciples as to the
existence of a Supreme Being
and also as to the existence of the Ego. His reply
in each case was noncommittal, and this may suggest
that in those days when barren metaphysical argument
was so prevalent he did not want to commit himself
to an answer which would have been equally distorted
by both sides. His conception of God and the human
soul may have been so deep as to be well nigh
impossible to express in words.
The view has been
put forward that the Buddha was silent on this
subject not because his idea of God was too small,
but because it was too great and could not be
intelligibly expressed, and so he did not wish to
restrict himself to a sharp definition of the Deity.
A consideration of his spiritual background and
environment will give weight to this claim that he
was not atheistic. It would be inevitable for one
brought up on the Upanishads and earlier religious
literature of Hinduism to believe in the existence
of Divine Spirit, the source of all our intellectual
powers and faculties as well as of all the powers of
nature, the great A tman immanent in the lesser,
finite atman of each man. To deny this would have
been the surest way of arousing the opposition of
every thinking religious Indian of his day, and we
know that the Buddha's message attracted many who
were sincerely seeking for reality. It is possible
that this atheistic development took place after the
Buddha's death and was one of the chief reasons for
the expulsion of Buddhism from India. For it is
strange that however strong Buddhism may be in
Judo-China, Ceylon and China, it has failed
completely in the land of its birth. |
 |
Whatever may be the truth about the Buddha and God,
there is no doubt that Buddhism in Burma or is
atheistic. The three main articles of the Buddhist
creed are Dokkha, Aneissa, Anatta—all is suffering,
all is impermanent, there is no soul or
self. According to this creed there can be
no God. To the Burmese Buddhist it is not a
case of weighing the evidence and taking one
side or |
|
the other ; to him there
is no question about it : the idea of God is not
only not reasonable but it is almost laughable. That
is his attitude in discussion and argument, but in
real life he is more vulnerable. For not a few of
them tend to put the Buddha in the place of God,
while to many belief in spirits is a far more real
thing than the absence of a Supreme Being. It would
seem that the great majority of people, like Nature,
abhor a vacuum, and if there is no God at the heart
of reality they look round for someone or something
to fill the vacant throne.
The Buddha himself did not claim to be divine. He
claimed to have found the way of escape from
suffering, to show men the road leading to Nirvana ;
he was a teacher and a guide, but not a savior. By
imitating his example they might become as he was,
but it was by their own effort and in their own
strength. When near death he is recorded to have
said to Ananda : 'Therefore, 0' Ananda, be ye lamps
unto yourselves. Be ye a refuge to yourselves.
Betake yourselves to no external refuge. Hold fast
to the Dhamma as a lamp.' And his last words were :
`Decay is inherent in all component things. Work out
your salvation with diligence.'
This lack of belief in a Supreme Being and in an
undying personality in men is regarded by many
friendly critics of Buddhism as its greatest
weakness. Such a negative faith cannot supply a
satisfying purpose for life, nor any real incentive
to great achievement. Indeed life in the world is
regarded as unfortunate and evil, something to be
escaped from. The goal of Nirvana, too, seems
negative and unsatisfying, especially to Western
minds with their emphasis on activity. It is the
most difficult of all Buddhist concepts to
understand. Nirvana is at any rate the cessation of
selfish desire, emancipation from the three cardinal
evils of lawba, dawtha, mantha,—lust, ill-will,
unreasoning stupidity ; it is the end of suffering,
the end of the weary recurring cycles of existence,
and so the Buddhist speaks of the Great Peace. It
must be something more than the peace of
nothingness, but it is difficult to think so without
a belief in personality. In one place the Scriptures
say : `the ceasing of becoming is Nirvana' ; you
have ceased to change and grow because you have
reached the goal, becoming and being are now one,
you have become that which you always aspired to be.
Is this its meaning ?
The most positive concept of it has been suggested
by a modern Buddhist* who compares Nirvana with
eternal life as taught by Jesus, and says it is a
quality of life possible now, the kind of life the
Buddha had, free from self-centredness, lust, This
fits in with the possibility of attaining Nirvana
while still in the world, and also with the refusal
of the Buddha to dogmatise about what happens after
the death of an araltant or Buddha. |
|
Dhamma Teaching, Law,
Truth
|
|

Teaching
Buddhism |
There being no God in Buddhism in it is obvious that
there can be little in the way of worship or prayer.
It ought not to be necessary to state that Buddhists
do not worship the image of the Buddha. They sit and
fix their eyes on the Buddha's image to remind them
of that great compassionate teacher and the way of
salvation which he taught ; that practice is an aid
to meditation and concentration.
Prayer too is not
addressed to anyone ; it is aspiration rather than
communion or petition. The nearest approach to
worship is found in the reverence which every
Buddhist renders to the Three Gems
I go for refuge to the Buddha.
I go for refuge to the Dhamma (Law).
I go for refuge to the Sangha (Brotherhood of
Monks). |
|
We have already dealt fairly fully with the first
of these objects of reverence in our consideration
of the life and teaching of the Buddha. We have now
to consider the other two. The Dhamma is the body of
teaching handed down by the Buddha to his disciples.
On his deathbed, before attaining to the final
Nirvana, he told them that the Dhamma was to be
their light and guide, and that the fulfillment of
the Dhamma would be the highest way of reverencing
himself. 'Whosoever, Ananda, be he brother or
sister, lay brother or lay sister,—whosoever walks
uprightly with the Dhamma-he it is that truly
honors, reveres, respects, worships, and defers to
the Blessed One in the perfection of worship.'
Buddhists in Burma or have tended to identify this
Teaching with the external law, written and
contained in the Ti-Pitaka, the three 'baskets' of
the Scriptures. These are : (I) Vinaya or
Discipline, containing the rules of life, intended
mainly for the monks. (2) The Sutta-Pitaka or
Discourses, including the four longer books—The
Dialogues of the Buddha, Further Dialogues of the
Buddha, Kindred Sayings, Gradual Sayings, and a
number of shorter ones of which the best known is
Dhammapada or Verses on Dhamma. To the ordinary
student of religion this collection is by far the
most interesting of the three, though it does not
make easy reading ; but patience will discover many
gems of thought and religious insight. There is a
good deal of repetition and a number of literary
devices, which point back to an oral tradition, when
the teaching was learnt by heart and handed down
from one generation of monks to the next. All the
main books in this section may be read in the
English translations published by the Pali Text
Society. (3) Abliidhanima, which describes the
processes of thought and psychology of Buddhism.
This is of a very metaphysical nature and makes more
difficult reading still. Strangely enough this is
the most popular of the three 'baskets' in ,
suggesting that Burmese Buddhists are more
interested in the metaphysical side than in the
ethical or religious aspects of their religion.
To the serious Buddhist the essence of the Teaching,
contained in the Scriptures, will consist of several
strands. There will be the insight of the Buddha
into the cause of suffering, and the way of release
in following the eightfold path ; there will be an
appreciation of the Law of Causation and its working
out in the law of karma—regarded from these aspects
Buddhism is certainly a `gnosis', a way of knowledge
and enlightenment. There will also be the ethical
teaching of the Buddha, summed up for the ordinary
man in the Five Great Commands, binding on every
Buddhist. These are :
1. To kill no living
thing.
2. Not to steal another's property.
3. Not to commit any sexual crime.
4. Not to speak what is untrue.
5. Not to drink intoxicating drinks.
The highly moral character of Buddhism is evident
from these five general commands. The first and the
last need some comment. Not only human life is
sacred, but all life,
that of animals and insects as
well. This is a logical development of the belief in
re-incarnation, that long recurring cycle of lives
progressing from humble forms of life and lower
standards of character, to that final existence in
the world when all guilt has been purged away, the
debt of karma fully paid, and from which is no
return ; Nirvana has been reached. So theoretically
all life is equally sacred, that of an insect or
animal equally valuable with that of a man. But in
practice Burmese Buddhists fall short of that
ideal—as indeed the adherents of any religion fall
woefully short of their highest aspirations. Murder
and violent crimes are sadly prevalent—murder is so
common that a murder trial is dismissed in the
newspapers with a short paragraph ; it is not of
front-page value as in the West. The crime
statistics of rival those of Chicago, so that
fearless critics of their Burmese friends have said
: 'Instead of exalting all life to the value of that
of a man the result has been to value the life of a
man no more than that of an animal or insect.' Yet
the devout monk will strain his water lest he
swallow a tiny insect, and the ordinary householder
will allow every pup born to live and will refuse to
put a pain-racked animal out of its misery.
The fifth command too is interesting in its complete
forbidding of the use of intoxicating liquor ; in
the case of strict Buddhists this extends to the use
of brandy for extreme cases of illness or
exhaustion. The strictness is probably due to a
practical understanding of human nature ; in the
East generally speaking, if a man drinks at all it
is not for fellowship or the stimulation of flagging
energy, but to get drunk, to forget his worries and
difficulties ; he has no idea of moderation. And in
that case abstinence is safer than temperance.
The ethical nature of Buddhism has been expressed in
another way : 'To abstain from evil ; to fulfill all
good ; to purify the heart—this is the teaching of
the Buddha.' To point out the failure of Buddhists
to live up to this high level is no valid criticism
of the standards of the Buddha, any more than the
confusion and failure of the West can be used as an
argument against the teaching of Christ. In both
cases it is a refusal to accept the highest
standards or a failure to find the spiritual power
necessary to put them into practice. If Christians
lived up to the teaching of Christ, and if Buddhists
put into practice the ethical teaching of the
Buddha, both West and East would be radically
different from what they are now.
A beautiful practice in Buddhism is meditation on
the four Brahinaviharas of inyitta (universal love
or goodwill), karuna (universal compassion),
nzudita (joy in the prosperity and happiness of
all), and upekkha (equanimity, indifference to the
ups-and-downs of life, non-attachment to the things
of this world). The object of this four-fold
meditation is not only to produce these four states
in oneself, but to radiate to all living beings
good-will, coin-passion, sympathetic joy, unshakable
poise.
In the Suttas there is a lovely description of the
whole duty of the Buddhist, and a version of this is
known and loved by every Burmese Buddhist. It is
called, |
The Song Of Blessing
One night a spirit came to the Blessed One and
addressed him thus in verse :
Many devas and men have pondered on blessings,
Longing for goodly things. 0 tell me Thou the
greatest blessing.
The Lord replied :
Not to follow after fools, but to follow after the
wise ; The worship of the worshipful,—this is the
greatest blessing.
To dwell in a pleasant spot, to have done good deeds
in former births,
To have set oneself in the right path,—this is the
greatest blessing
Much learning and much science, and a discipline
well learned,
Yea, and a pleasant utterance,—this is the greatest
blessing.
The support of mother and father, the cherishing of
child and wife,
To follow a peaceful livelihood,—this is the
greatest blessing.
Giving alms, the righteous life, to cherish kith and
kin, And to do deeds that bring no blame,—this is
the greatest blessing.
To cease and to abstain from sin, to shun
intoxicants ; And steadfastness in
righteousness,—this is the greatest blessing.
Reverence, humility, content, and gratitude,
To hear the Law at proper times,—this is the
greatest blessing.
Patience, the soft answer, the sight of those
controlled, And pious talk in season clue,—this is
the greatest blessing.
Restraint, the holy life, discernment of the Noble
Truths, Of one's own self to know the Goal,—this is
the greatest blessing.
A heart untouched by worldly things, a heart that is
not swayed. By sorrow, a heart passionless,
secure,—that is the greatest blessing.
Invincible on every side, they go who do these
things On every side they go to bliss,—theirs is the
greatest blessing.
To follow this noble life brings merit and helps a
man on his long pilgrimage to Nirvana. Perhaps the
acquisition of merit has become too dominating a
motive for living the highest life, and as has been
said earlier the most meritorious deeds are those
connected with the institutional side of Buddhism ;
yet in daily life you will find many a sign of
thoughtful charity—often along the roadside you
will see a tiny miniature house, high on posts like
the living houses, built of wood, containing pots of
drinking water, daily replenished by some kindly
person for the refreshment of thirsty wayfarers ; or
in almost every village a zavat or rest house where
travelers may spread out their bedding rolls and
sleep under cover ; or a village well provided by
some villager who loves his fellow men. There are
very few homeless orphans in ; if the parents
die a kindly neighbor will often adopt the children
; there is a whole section of traditional Buddhist
law dealing with the rights of adopted children.
Even the pariah dogs and birds are fed.
The spirit of toleration inculcated by Buddhism
flourishes in Burma or . Where there is intolerance it
is due
not to religion, but to a sensitive nationalism,
which regards Buddhism as the religion of and
therefore considers it unpatriotic of a n to
accept conversion to another religion. And it must
be said that sometimes missionaries in their
approach are neither tolerant nor tactful, failing
to appreciate the spiritual stature of the Buddha
and the goodness and beauty of much of the Buddhist
teaching.
A word perhaps needs to be said about the absence of
any caste or class distinctions in . This is
due, I think, to the value and equality of all
living beings implicit in the Buddha's teaching,
although in his time caste distinctions in India had
not yet hardened into their later rigidity ; they
were there, but in their original purpose of
practical division of responsibility and labour. Nor
do we find the class distinctions so common in the
West. ns meet one another and people of other
races with a delightful absence of caste or class
consciousness, with no complexes of superiority or
inferiority.
So when the devout Buddhist begins his religious
exercises with his homage to the Three Gems, in
reverencing the second gem, the Dhamma, he has in
mind some or all of the above ideas.
In recent years Mrs. Rhys Davids, following up the
principles of the higher and textual criticism which
have been brought to bear on the Christian
Scriptures, has attempted to get back behind
received writings and traditions to the original
message of the Buddha. To her mind the Dhamma is not
an external code of teaching but more of an inner
principle, an inner light and guide approaching the
idea of conscience. She claims that originally this
was akin to the idea of Holy Spirit. The handful of
Burmese Buddhists who have read her recent books
will have nothing to do with this theory, yet
strangely enough Mrs. Rhys Davids has some support
of an historical basis, in the existence in of
a sect of Buddhists who call themselves Paramats,
the name apparently meaning followers of the higher
way as compared with the Pinyats or adherents of the
Law. These Paramats believe in a Divine Wisdom,
somewhat akin to the Logos idea of the Stoics, and
later of Philo, with which men may enter into
communion by purification and meditation. They have
no use for monks or pagodas or external symbols ;
the highest form of life to them is that of the
hermit, who by fasting and prayer seeks to get into
mystical relationship with the ultimate reality.
Some of these hermits, independently of
Christianity, have conic to the conclusion that
there must be an Eternal God.
The Sangha
The third object of reverence and source of refuge
is the Sangha or Community of Monks.
After his enlightenment the Buddha founded an order
of monks, who under his training were to attain to Arahants or Enlightened Ones and then spread his
gospel to men. His first disciples were five ascetic
wanderers with whom he had lived for a time in his
earlier search for truth. These were converted as a
result of his first sermon at Benares, the sutta of
turning the wheel of the doctrine. A little later
two Brahman ascetics, Sariputta and Mogallana,
joined him and attained quickly to the status of
arahants. The Buddha made these two his chief
disciples. Perhaps the best known of the early
disciples is Ananda, who
became
the Buddha's personal attendant, and by his
faithfulness and affection earned the title of the
'beloved disciple'. He was spiritually the most
immature of all the disciples and in the Scriptures
is constantly asking questions which however result
in the clarifying of the Buddha's teaching. He did
not attain to complete enlightenment until after the
Buddha's death in 483 B.C., but such was the
reverence in which he was held that at the Council
which followed the Buddha's death the version of the
Dhamina which he recited (Sutta-Pitaka) was accepted
as the standard. Besides a 'beloved disciple',.
Buddhism also has a Judas ; this was Devadatta, a
powerful disciple who when the Buddha became
advanced in age suggested that lie should resign and
that the leadership of the Order should be vested in
himself. This was refused and from that time the
enmity of Devadatta increased until finally he was
expelled from the Order. Even then he plotted with a
hostile rajah to kill the Buddha.
At the time of the Buddha's death there was a large
body of monks and this continued to grow. There are
over 200.000 monks in Burma or alone. These must not be
thought of as priests in the Christian sense of the
word, for there is no ritual or prayer in Buddhism.
They are primarily concerned with their own quest
for enlightenment and Nirvana, though many of them
expound the Law for the benefit of the laity, and.
all of them afford a means of gaining merit to their
dayakas or supporters.
The original name of the monk was Bliikkhu, meaning
mendicant or homeless one. But in he is. known
as Pon-gyi meaning 'Great Glory', thus showing the
great reverence in which he is held by the people,
who in speaking to him use a whole set of honorific
words to describe his daily actions : thus he does
not 'walk', he `processes', he does not 'speak' but
'pronounces', he does not 'sleep' but 'reposes'.
The Brotherhood consists of two classes—the novices
(Koyin) and the fully ordained monks (Utazin). The
novice observes the five great commands binding on
all Buddhists and in addition five more of a
disciplinary and ascetic nature :
1. Not to take food after noon.
2. Not to sit on high seats or couches (this
indicating pride and luxury)
3. Not to use personal adornments, unguents, etc.
4. To abstain from witnessing dancing, shows and
plays (now-a-days more honored in the breach than in
the observance).
5. Not to accept or use money in any form.
Any male of over seven years of age may be ordained
as a novice and in practice almost every Burma or Burmese boy
enters the monastery for a period, it may be for a
Lent, or a year or several years, or even for as
short a period as a fortnight. Any fully ordained
novice may leave the Order at will at any time.
Until he becomes a novice a Burmese lad is not
looked upon as having come to maturity either in
religion or in membership of the nation.
In commemoration of the Great Renunciation, the
entry of a boy into the Novitiate is frequently made
the occasion of one of those public festivals which
delight the play-

movement- and color-loving Burmese
heart. Even poor parents will often save money for
some time (a very hard task for the generous and,
indeed, thriftless n) in order, to give their
sons a lavish Shin-Ptu (making a Holy One), as the
festival is called ; and the Shin-pyu of a rich
man's son is often a very grand affair.
Personifying the Prince Siddhattha, the boy is
dressed in regal robes and crowned ; and, after
receiving all his friends in state, the little
Prince rides round the village, mounted,. if
possible,
on a white horse, in memory of white Kanthaka, the Bodhisatta's steed. A procession is
formed, and amidst a great display of royal canopies
and insignia, hired for the occasion from some
theatrical company, it marches to the air of
stirring music round the village to the Monastery
walls. Here the Princeling must dismount and music
must stop, for the little mystery-play has reached
the point corresponding to the arrival of the
Bodhisatta at the River Anoma, when He put off His
royal robes and donned the ascetic's garb. Entering
the compound, the lad bathes. and is clad in a
temporary plain white robe ; and, so attired, makes
his request, in the ancient Pali formula, that the
ordaining Monk will, 'out of Compassion, and for the
sake of the Attainment of Nirvana's Peace', grant
him the Yellow Robe. The Monk, assenting, gives him
the parcel of Three Robes, placed ready to Ins hand.
The lad retires and robes himself in these, after
having his head shaved ; he then returns to the
Monastery, where the ceremony of Ordination is
completed by his recitation of the vow to observe
the Ten Precepts of a Novice.
In the monastery the novice acts as attendant to the
monks, studies his religion from the sacred books,
and joins in the morning and evening religious
exercises of the Order.
To become a full monk a man must be at least twenty
Years old, must be free from debt, government
service, and certain diseases and deformities. He
can only be ordained by a senior monk of at least
ten years' standing in the presence of a chapter of
at least ten fully-ordained monks. The office of
ordination handed down from earliest times is read
out by the senior monk in Pali, and sometimes in
Burmese as well, as an understanding of the
classical religious language of Buddhism is not
likely to be an accomplishment of the new monk so
early in his career. For five years after ordination
the new monk remains under the instruction of an
Achariya, and when he has acquired ten years of
seniority in the Order he becomes a Them or Elder
and can then confer ordination on others and act as
the abbot of a community of monks.
The monk has to observe no less than 227 rules, his
whole life being regulated for him. There are four
deadly sins which involve immediate expulsion from
the Order—the breaking of the rule of chastity, the
taking by fraud or violence of anything not given to
him, the taking of human life, and the laying claim
falsely to arahantship or the possession of any
superior or superhuman powers. He may own only
eight possessions—the three garments composing the
Yellow Robe, his begging bowl, his girdle, his
water-strainer, a razor to shave his head, and a
needle to repair his robes. The novice too may not
own more than this.
There are two important monastic practices which
have survived from the time of the Buddha. The first
is the Uhosatha or fortnightly chapter at which the
list of offences given in the Vinaya is recited and
confession is made by each monk of infringements.
The second is the keeping of the Buddhist Lent (Wa)
which covers three months of the Rainy Season ; this
period is to be devoted to religious retreat, and
travelling is forbidden. In the Buddhist Lent
is opened and closed by two great festivals which
in their social nature and hospitality do much to
compensate the pleasure-loving Burmese for the
quietness and sobriety of the period between.
Every morning the younger monks and the novices
accompanied by some of the boys of the monastery
school, `sons of the monastery' as they are called,
go out in silent procession to beg their daily
supply of food. Each monk or novice carries a black
earthen or lacquer begging bowl and as the
procession comes to the house of a known supporter
it stops and a member of the household will come out
and put an offering of rice in each bowl and perhaps
a portion of curry in the receptacles carried by the
attendant boys. No word will be spoken, either of
request or thanks, for the monks are doing the laity
a favor in allowing them to acquire merit, and eyes
will be discreetly cast to the ground for the monk
must not look upon a woman, lest fleshly lust be
aroused.
On the return to the monastery the food will be
reheated and eaten before noon. But nowadays in
some of the less strict monasteries the food
collected is given to the boys and the dogs and a
more palatable meal is eaten which has been given by
wealthy supporters and cooked while the monks are
out on their morning round. The rest of the day is
passed by the monks in studying the Scriptures,
teaching the younger monks and the novices, or in
the practice of meditation.
In the old days, before mission and government
education became so general, there was a school
attached to almost every monastery, in which the
boys of the village were taught reading, writing,
some elementary arithmetic and the principles of
their religion. The teaching methods in most of
these schools were primitive and the boys learnt
most of what they did, by heart, shouting out the
lesson after the teacher. Yet the result was that
almost all Burmese boys learnt to read, making
the most literate country in the East. In addition
they received a good deal of instruction in the
Buddhist religion at an impressionable age and this
combined with the custom of every boy becoming a
novice for a shorter or longer period helps to
explain the hold which Buddhism has on the people of
.
In it is assumed that to carry out the
eightfold path and extinguish all the fires of
craving and desire, it is essential to abandon
ordinary life in the world and become a monk. Thus
it is not uncommon for an elderly n, who has
retired from public service and whose family is
grown up or otherwise sufficiently provided for, to
forsake the world, take the monk's robe and spend
his declining years in that religious self-culture
which advances him on the road to Arahantship and
Nirvana.
This insistence on the necessity of leaving the
world and becoming a monk is not seen in the
teaching of the Buddha, although he undoubtedly held
that the monk was freer to pursue the goal. One day
he was asked by a layman : 'Must I give up my
wealth, my home and my business enterprises and,
like you, go into homelessness in order to attain
the bliss of the religious life?'
And the Buddha replied : 'The bliss of the religious
life is attainable by everyone who walks in the
noble eightfold path. He that cleaves to wealth had
better cast it away than allow his heart to be
poisoned by it; but he who does not cleave to
wealth, and possessing riches uses them rightly,
will be a blessing unto his fellow-beings. I say
unto thee, remain in thy station of life and apply
thyself with diligence to thy enterprises. It is not
life and wealth and power that enslave men, but the
cleaving to life and wealth and power.
The Dhamma of the Tathagata does not require a man
to go into homelessness or to resign the world
unless he feels called upon to do so ; but the
Dhamma of the Tathagata requires every man to free
himself from the illusion of self, to cleanse his
heart, to give up his thirst for pleasure, and lead
a life of righteousness.
And whatever men do, whether they remain in the
world as artisans, merchants, and officers of any
kind, or retire from the world and devote themselves
to a life of religious meditation, let them put
their whole heart into their task ; let them be
diligent and energetic, and if they are like the
lotus, which, although it grows in the water, yet
remains untouched by the water, if they struggle in
life without cherishing envy or hatred, if they live
in the world not a life of self but a life of truth,
then surely joy, peace and bliss will dwell in their
minds.
Decline In The Burmese
Sangha
In recent years the Brotherhood of Monks in
has suffered a serious decline, both in the
reputation and respect in which it is held by the
laity and also in its influence on the moral and
spiritual life of the country. This is not entirely
due to internal causes. For in the days of the
Burmese Kings the Sangha was strictly controlled
through an archbishop or Thathanabaing appointed by
the King and responsible for the monastic discipline
throughout the country. With the annexation of Upper
in 1886, the British Government with its
recognised principle of neutrality in religious
affairs, allowed this important office to lapse and
so since that time there has been no co-ordinating
or controlling nucleus in Burmese Buddhism. The
result has been that the discipline in individual
monasteries has depended entirely on the presiding
abbot : in some cases strict standards of moral life
and monastic discipline have been preserved, in
others there has been sad laxity in both those
spheres. In recent years monks have involved
themselves in politics, especially some of the
younger ones and have helped to stir up violent
nationalistic feeling. The monastery too has often
been looked upon as a sanctuary for Burmese
criminals and the ease with which a man may become a
novice has encouraged this. In Rangoon for example a
big block of monasteries in Godwin Road was often a
source of anxiety and trouble. There is obviously a
need of some official register of monks and a
stricter scrutiny of those who present themselves
for the novitiate. It has been suggested that in the
reconstruction of after the war the ancient
office of Thathanabaing should be revived and that
he should be assisted by advisory bodies of trusted
monks and devout laymen. It is possible that
something more far-reaching than this is necessary
and that Buddhism should be made the state religion
of with an annual grant for furthering truly
religious objects. In Siam the King is regarded as
the sole defender of the faith and many of the
monasteries are under his direct control and in
these a stricter rule of life is observed.
It must not be thought that this unhappy state is
completely acquiesced in, for many monks and leading
laymen deplore it and there have been efforts to
remedy it. Only a year or two ago a bill was to have
been presented to the Legislative Council by a
leading Buddhist to provide some control of the Sangha but was withdrawn at the last moment as the
mover was violently threatened while on the way to
the Council Chamber.
And in every generation there have been monks of
outstanding piety and learning. Twenty-five years
ago the saintly Ledi
Sayadaw became a great
spiritual force in the life of the people, and in
many a town in Lower his teaching is still
remembered and practiced. In recent years there has
been the Monyin Sayadaw who has organized a powerful
Buddhist centre near Monywa
wherever he goes, crowds flock to hear him for he
speaks simply and directly to the moral needs of the
people, and where this is so there will always be
plenty of people eager to listen and learn. After
the Rebellion in 1931 many Buddhist monks
toured the affected areas preaching peace and
goodwill, and in the rehabilitation of after
this war the monks will have a still greater part to
play.
But it must be admitted that there is a real doubt
as to whether or not a country like Burma or can
support as many as 100,000 monks. Economically such
a large number is a serious drain on the country,
and it is to be questioned whether it is morally
healthy for so many men in the prime of life not to
be doing some really creative work. In the Christian
monasteries of the Middle Ages, under the influence
of S. Benedict and his order, the twin principles of
work and prayer were accepted, and from the
monasteries there came out not only religion and
learning but much practical inspiration for the
development of agriculture and industry. If the
Buddhist rule could be modified to include manual
labor what a difference it would make to the
thinking and life of the people generally ; possibly
with the spiritual aristocracy doing manual work the
rising generation would come to see that manual work
was at least as praiseworthy and valuable as a
routine job in a government office, which seems to
be the extent of ambition at present.
To pursue the high moral life laid down by the
Buddha, to point men ever to the rooting out of all
selfishness, to live worthy of the great reverence
in which they are held by the people—these are no
mean aims for the monks of , and their
achievement in any degree would augur a spiritual
and moral revival among the people of , already
one of the most friendly and loveable races in the
world.
We may close our study of the monks with words taken
from the Buddha's charge when he sent them out on
their mission : 'Go ye, 0 Bhikkhus, and wander forth
for the gain of the many, for the welfare of the
many, in compassion for the world, for the good, for
the gain, for the welfare of gods and men. Proclaim,
0 Bhikkhus, the Doctrine glorious, preach ye a life
of holiness, perfect and pure.'
How Buddhism Came To
Burma-
The popularly accepted tradition is that Buddhism
came to through two Talaing merchants, Taposa
and Palika, who were converted by the Buddha and to
whom he gave eight hairs of his head which he
instructed them to deposit in the Theinguttara Hill
beside the relics of the three Buddhas who preceded
him. They returned to and searched far and
wide for Theinguttara Hill, which was finally
pointed out to them by the aged Sule nat. Here they
enshrined the hairs in a pagoda which came to be
later known as the Shwe Dagon, one of the most
sacred Buddhist shrines in the East. A pagoda was
later built to commemorate the rat who had pointed
out the sacred site ; this is the present Sule
Pagoda which stands in the centre of the city of
Rangoon. A more probable tradition is that which
states that Buddhism was brought to by two
monks, Sona and Uttara, who were sent out by the
Third General Council, summoned under the patronage
of the great Emperor Asoka, who flourished in India
about 25o B.C. After his victorious war against the
Kalingas, in which 15o,000 men were killed, Asoka
filled with remorse and horror was converted to
Buddhism. Shortly afterwards he entered the Sangha
and for the rest of his reign ruled on Buddhist and
philanthropic principles. After the third Buddhist
Council missionaries were sent out to Kashmir,
Ceylon, Egypt, Greece, Syria—to these places vouched
for by Asoka's Stone Edicts, tradition has added
and tradition is possibly correct. The monks
Sona and Uttara are said to have landed at Thaton,
which was then a seaport, though now some twenty
miles inland.
Little more is known of the progress of Buddhism in
until the 1th century A.D. when it was so
flourishing at
Thaton that there were thirty sets
of Pali Scriptures in the royal library there.
Meanwhile a decadent form of Buddhism had penetrated
into Central , probably one of the Tantric
magic-working sects which had sprung up in India
during the period of Buddhist decline and had
entered by the overland route from Tibet. The
priests of this degenerate faith were called Ari and
indulged in superstitious and immoral rites. The
King of Pagan, Anawrahta, had been greatly
influenced by a monk, Shin Arahan, who presented
himself at his court and before long became the
King's chief religious adviser. At Shin Arahan's
suggestion Anawrahta sent to the King of Thaton
asking for copies of the Buddhist Scriptures, and
when this request was insultingly refused, attacked
and sacked Thaton and carried off all the Sacred
Books as well as much other booty. It must have been
a triumphant procession which returned to Pagan,
thirty-two white elephants loaded with thirty sets
of the Scriptures as well as many sacred relics. The
Scriptures were housed in the Ti-pitaka-taik or
library, which may still be seen at Pagan. The
result of studying them, combined with the pressure
of Shin Arahan, was that Anawrahta decided to adopt
the pure Buddhism of Thaton as the state religion.
The superstitious Ari were given the choice of
joining the orthodox Sangha or of becoming lay
officials of government. From that time on Anawrahta
became a Burmese Asoka and, ably aided by Shin
Arahan, set in motion a whole era of religious
reform, temple-building and philanthropic projects.
The Bagan period, 1044-1287, was the golden age of
both secular and religious history in .
Numerous pagodas were built which for architectural
design and strength rivalled the Norman cathedrals
which were being built at the same time in Europe,
and in the opinion of some equalled them in beauty.
Even today deserted though it is, Pagan with its
sixteen square miles of pagodas and religious
buildings is one of the wonders of the world.
In 1071, the King of Ceylon, whose country had been
ravaged by a bitter Hindu persecution, sent to Anawrahta for a set of the Scriptures and for monks
to secure a chapter for valid ordination. Anawrahta
sent these, and in return asked for the sacred
Buddha Tooth, Ceylon's priceless relic. This was not
unreasonably refused, but his messengers were given
a duplicate, for the original Tooth had the faculty
of miraculously and conveniently reproducing itself
to provide for the expanding religion. Its arrival
at Pagan was the occasion of another triumphant
procession : the king himself waded out into the
river and bore the sacred relic on his head to be
enshrined in the Shwezigon pagoda with other Buddha
relics. Anawrahta's action in sending monks to
Ceylon was repaid more than once in, the history of
Burmese Buddhism, for when the number of genuinely
ordained monks became so low as to threaten the true
succession, missions were sent from Ceylon to ensure
its unbroken continuance.
Anawrahta's successors continued his policy of
religious patronage and temple-building. His son Kyansittha, 1084-1112, was as fortunate as his
father in having for the whole of his reign Shin
Arahan as Primate and adviser. A mission was sent to
India to restore the shrine at Buddha-gaya, where
grows the sacred Bo tree under which the Buddha had
become enlightened. Kyan-sittha also built the
lovely Ananda pagoda, in the Western aisle of which
can still be seen two life-size figures of himself
and Shin Arahan kneeling at the feet of a gigantic
image of the Buddha.
Shin Arahan died in 1115 at the age of 71 ; it is to
him more than to any other person that we owe the
establishment of the pure form of Hinayana Buddhism
in , and the era of pagoda-building and
inscriptions which he inaugurated was the most
creative age in 's history.
The Bagan kingdom broke up in '287 ; for years it
had been weakening and none of its later kings had
been men of any great note, but the immediate cause
was the invasion of the Chinese to whom Pagan had
been nominally tributary for some time. Harvey in
his History of pays the following inspired
tribute to this dynasty of temple-builders : 'The
legacy of their fleeting sway enriched posterity for
ever. It was they who made the sun-scorched
wilderness, the solitary plain of Myingyan, to
blossom forth into the architectural magnificence of
Pagan. . . . To them the world owes in great measure
the preservation of Theravada Buddhism, one of the
purest faiths mankind has ever known. Brahmanism had
strangled it in the land of its birth. In Ceylon its
existence was threatened again and again. East of
it was not yet free from priestly corruptions.
But the Kings of never wavered, and at Pagan
the stricken faith found a city of refuge.
Vainglorious tyrants build themselves sepulchers,
but none of these men has a tomb. . . . These men's
magnificence went to glorify their religion, not to
deck the tent wherein they camped during this
transitory life.'
The break-up of the Bagan kingdom was followed by a
period of
Shan invasion. These were naturally years
of confusion, and Buddhism shared in the general
decline. Religion languished, the clergy split up
into sects, though pagodas were built none of them
could rival even the lesser temples of Pagan. It was
not until Damma-zedi, 1472-1492, that a revival
came. He built some beautiful pagodas at Pegu,
modelled on the temple at Buddha-gaya to which he
sent a mission. But his most important work was the
mission of twenty-two monks which he sent to Ceylon
in 1475. These monks receive valid ordination from
the monks of the ancient Maha-vihara monastery
founded in 251 B.C., and on their return they
transmitted these orders to the clergy throughout
, thus giving some measure of unity to the
Sangha as well as reviving religion. Among the monks
who went on this mission was Buddhaghosa, who
translated the earliest Burmese law-book the Wareru
Dhamma-that, based on the laws of Mann brought by
Hindu colonists to centuries before. He also
wrote various commentaries. Burmese historians have
identified him with the famous Buddhaghosa who was
born in n0 and translated many of the Scriptures and
commentaries from Singalese into Pali, the author of
The Path of Purity. But Burmese historians have a
naive way of identifying places and personalities
mentioned in the Scriptures and commentaries with
places and personalities in , without however
much real foundation. The truth is that the early
history of Buddhism in has been lost, and
writers convinced of its long standing in the
country have sought to make good the lack.
As the
history of Burma
or unfolds itself with its
continuous internal wars and its periodic invasions
of Siam and Arakan, Buddhism still retains its
influence. Kings build pagodas, dedicate slaves,
endow monasteries with paddy land ; sometimes under
the influence of the religion a king will abandon
some cruel custom, as when Bayinnaung, 1561-1581,
after conquering the Shan States suppressed the
custom of slaughtering too each of men and women,
too horses and to elephants to be the retinue on his
last journey of any sawbwa who died.
With the 16th century came adventurers and traders
from the West, first the Portuguese, then the Dutch,
French and English. Captain Alex. Hamilton, who
visited Syriam in 17o9, pays a striking tribute to
the humanity and hospitality of the old-time
priesthood of : 'When shipwrecked mariners
come to their Baws, they find a great deal of
hospitality, both in food and raiment, and have
letters of recommendation from the Priests of one
Convent to those of another on the road they design
to travel, where they may expect vessels to
transport them to Syriam ; and if any be sick or
maim'd, the Priests, who are the Peguers chief
Physicians, keep them in their Convent, till they
are cured, and then furnish them with letters, as is
above observed, for they never enquire which way a
stranger worships God, but if he is human, he is the
object of their charity.'
In 1784-5 King Bodawpaya invaded Arakan and brought
away the great
Maha-muni image of the Buddha. It was
taken on rafts to Sandoway and thence over the
Taungup pass to Padaung below Prome, and thence up
the Irrawaddy to be enshrined in the Arakan pagoda
at Mandalay, a tremendous triumph of transport.
Bodawpaya also acquired what he believed to be the
Buddha Tooth from Ceylon. At home he attempted to
reform the monks. His religious and secular triumphs
evidently turned his brain, for he thought himself
destined to be a world conqueror, and not content
with this claimed to be the final Buddha. This
latter claim however was firmly rejected by the
monks.
In 1871 King Mindon summoned 2,400 clergy to
Mandalay to attend the Fifth Buddhist Council. The
Fourth had been held in Ceylon nineteen centuries
previously. The assembled monks following the
custom of the earlier councils, recited the Buddhist
Scriptures, and the accepted text was engraved on
729 marble slabs erected in the Kutho-daw pagoda.
Although only Burmese clergy had been invited Mindon
received the proud title of `Convener of the Fifth
Great Synod'. As a memorial of this council King
Mindon presented a new spire to the Shwe Dagon
pagoda, coated with gold and studded with jewels,
costing £62,000.
With the annexation of Upper in 1885 Buddhism
ceased to be the state religion of any part of
. Harvey in the Cambridge History of India has
the following interesting and pungent paragraph : `Th
King was head of the Buddhist Church. His chaplain
was a primate who prevented schism, managed church
lands, and administered clerical discipline, through
an ecclesiastical commission appointed and paid by
the King. The primate prepared the annual clergy
list, giving particulars of age and ordination,
district by district, and any person who claimed to
be a cleric and was not in the list was punished. A
district governor was precluded by benefit of the
clergy from passing judgment on a criminous cleric,
but he framed the trial record and submitted it to
the palace ; the primate passed orders, unfrocking
the cleric and handing him over to secular justice.
In 1887, the primate and thirteen bishops met the
commander-inchief, Sir Frederick Roberts, offering
to preach submission to the English in every village
throughout the land, if their jurisdiction was
confirmed. The staff trained by the English in Lower
for two generations included Burmese Buddhist
extra commissioners who could have represented the
chief commissioner on the primate's board. But
English administrators, being citizens of the modern
secularist state, did not even consider the
primate's proposal ; they merely expressed polite
benevolence, and the ecclesiastical commission
lapsed. Today schism is rife, any charlatan can
dress as a cleric and swindle the faithful, and
criminals often wear the robe and live in a
monastery to elude the police. As Sir Edward Sladen,
one of the few Englishmen who had seen native
institutions as they really were, said, the English
non-possumus was not neutrality but interference in
religion.'
Women In Buddhist
The attitude of the Buddha to women was one of
distrust and suspicion typical of monastic sentiment
all the world over. This is brought out in some of
his conversations with Ananda who frequently
advocated the cause of women.
`Master,' says Ananda, 'how shall we behave before
women ?'
`You should shun their gaze, Ananda'.
`But if we see them, Master, what are we to do ?'
`Not speak to them, Ananda.'
But if we do speak to them, what then ?'
`Then you must watch over yourselves, Ananda!'
Clearly the Buddha regarded women as the most
attractive and dangerous of all those snares which
arouse the physical senses. Yet it can be claimed
that he called on men and women alike to abandon the
sexual nature and set out on the long road to
spiritual maturity.
He did riot refuse the hospitality and alms of
devout laywomen and there are a number of well-known
women who were allowed to minister to the needs of
himself and the Sangha and so gain merit towards
their own ultimate enlightenment.
In response to repeated pleas from Ananda the Buddha
at last gave permission for women to enter the
Sangha and an order of Bhikkhuni or Sisters was
founded. But his permission was given reluctantly
and safeguarded by regulations which made it clear
that the eldest ordained sister must behave with
extreme humility even to the most junior monk. But
this gave them their chance to show their worth and,
as Mrs. Rhys Davids comments, 'it is clear that, by
intellectual and moral eminence, a sister might
claim equality with the highest of the fraternity'.
The claim was made good in the Psalms of the Sisters
in which the songs of those who attained to
Arahantship are preserved. This fact, generally
ignored, shows that the attainment of Nirvana is
possible in this life even to women.
In Burma or the Order of the Sisters has not been
maintained, although there are meithila, 'nuns' so
called, who live a semi-monastic life, a half-way
house between the old Order of Sisters and the
domestic life common to most women. They wear a
special robe of their own, possess a certain amount
of property, do their own marketing and domestic
work. They are not held in anything like as much
esteem as the monks. A Burmese saying runs : 'Only
if you have lost your child, or your husband has
left you, or you have failed in trade, or got badly
into debt, will you become a nun.'
As to the women of
Burma or generally, theoretically
their only hope is to be reborn as men so that they
may become monks and so attain Nirvana. But in
practice the women of are the freest of all
the women in the East, and although tacitly paying
lip service to the superiority of men (the Burma
or Burmese
woman always addresses her husband or any other man
as shin, lord), yet they are very much the equal
companions of men. In Buddhist Law if husband and
wife separate each takes the dowry brought by him or
her to the marriage, together with half the increase
that has been added during the years they have lived
together. The Burmese women are intelligent and
capable ; many friendly observers regard them as
having more backbone and character than the men.
They take an active share in the management of the
home, much of the petty trade of the country is in
their capable hands, while in the villages they
share with their men-folk the work of planting and
harvesting.
As in the West, the women are the chief supporters
of religion. They are much more regular in their
visits to the pagoda, more often in prayer before
the images of the Buddha, more generous in the daily
support of the monks.
Belief In Spirits
All the indigenous races of Burma or have come from the
mountainous regions of the Tibetan and Chinese
borders, pressing down the great river valleys
towards the fertile land of the south, where nature
is generous and life easy. Before they settled in
Central or Southern Burma or the Burmese people were
animists as the hill tribes still are to-day. They
worshipped the spirit of the spring or river, the
tree spirit or nat of the great banyan tree, they
propitiated the spirits of nature and those
responsible for sickness and disease, and they
feared the spirits of the dead. Much of this still
survives to-day in spite of the fact that Buddhism
is the accepted religion of the country.
The word nat may have two meanings in Burmese. It
may refer to the devas, the spiritual beings who
inhabit the six Buddhist heavens in which virtuous
people are rewarded with happiness after a good life
on the earth. These beings display great solicitude
for the pious state and welfare of mankind, but you
need not bother about them too much for they will
not do you any harm.
Secondly, the word nat may refer to the spirits of
nature, the spirits of the air, the forest, the
water, the household nat, the nat of the village.
These are generally, though not always, regarded as
malevolent ; they may do you either good or harm,
and so they must be propitiated by regular
offerings. There is a nat-sin or shrine for the
local spirits in each village ; in most homes a
cokernut decorated in red cloth is hung up for the
guardian nat of the home ; at every big banyan tree
there will be a shrine for the tree-spirit at which
gold leaf, candles, flowers will be offered. All
these spirits are to be feared because of their
potentiality for doing harm.
There are also powerful spirits connected with
certain localities, the spirits of people who in
past generations have met with a violent end and are
now believed to roam around the scene of their death
seeking whom they may devour. The early legends in
Burmese vernacular histories deal largely with this
type of nats. Some of the most popular festivals,
though centring round the pagodas, are in origin nat
festivals. In 1856 at the founding of Mindon's new
capital of Mandalay, pregnant women were buried
alive under the posts of the main gates, the idea
being that their spirits would haunt the place and
do harm to any who came against it with evil intent.
Among the Karens and Kachins animism plays a more
powerful part than among the ns, but even among
the latter the nats are to be reckoned with in
everyday life, so much so that it has been claimed
that animism is the real religion of Burma or and that
Buddhism is only a veneer.
Anawrahta, the founder-patron of Burmese Buddhism,
realized how difficult it would be to detach his
people from their old beliefs and practices, for in
the great Shwe Dagon Pagoda at Pagan, he enshrined
images of the thirty-seven nats, saying, 'If they
will not come for the new religion, they must come
for the old'.
It should be understood that this worship of the
spirits is quite contrary to Buddhism ; it is
tolerated rather than permitted. Its existence side
by side with Buddhism is thoroughly illogical, but
then the n is illogical in more ways than one :
as a Buddhist he confesses that `all is suffering'
but in practice he is a gay, pleasure-loving,
happy-go-lucky fellow. Perhaps too Buddhism may
satisfy him as a philosophy of life and as an outlet
for social activity, but it is cold and impersonal,
whereas his contact with the nats is more satisfying
to that inner, religious sense of dependence and
need.
This belief in spirits is accompanied by a natural
faith in omens. There are all kinds of auspicious
and inauspicious omens, certain days on which it is
unlucky to commence a journey or undertake a new
project. And inevitably there are plenty of experts,
who profess to be able to interpret the signs or
foretell the auspicious days. These be-din say as,
astrologers, ponnas, will for an appropriate fee
tell your horoscope or advise you as to lucky days,
or tell you the whereabouts of a lost person or
piece of property. Superstitious practices, relics
of primitive magic, love potions, still survive and
are well patronised. The best monks frown on all
this, urging their people to protect themselves by
reciting the usual religious formula or verses of
the Scriptures, against which the wills of the nats
etc. are harmless. But superstition and the desire
to know the future are so far too strong even for
the disapproval of the monks, who have perforce to
tolerate what they would fain banish.
Festivals
Mention has already been made of the festivals,
which are more of the nature of great social
holidays. Many of these are the patronal festivals
of pagodas, some are even nat festivals, not all of
them have any connection with Buddhism. The New Year
Feast or Thin-gyan known to Western people as the
Water Festival is almost the only festival that is
observed universally throughout . This takes
place early in April and celebrates the annual visit
of the Thagya-min or King of the Devas to inaugurate
the new year. The exact day is fixed each year by
the astrologers who profess to have intimate
knowledge of his plans, and who also announce
whether he will stay on the earth for three days or
four. Early on the first day crowds repair to the
monastery with pots of fresh clear water which are
respectfully offered to the monks, then the images
at the pagoda are ceremonially washed. After that
the festival becomes one joyous holiday and water is
sprinkled or more often thrown over anybody and
everybody, the idea behind it being friendliness
and cleansing. In former times there was a deeper
thought to the festival —children would not fail to
visit their parents and sprinkling them with a few
drops of water would ask pardon for their
negligence's of the past year ; a similar thought
would lurk behind the offering of water to the monks
; officials and employers would receive visits from
their juniors and would be sprinkled with water
symbolic of blessing, good-will and respect. But in
modern times the festival tends to degenerate into a
rollicking time especially for the younger folk,
with buckets, hose-pipes, squirts, stirrup pumps all
brought into play, with trams, trains, buses,
motor-cars as the favourite targets so that on these
festival days it is risky to go out unless you are
prepared for repeated soakings. But among the
ns themselves it is all carried on with
friendliness and enjoyment, and no one minds
getting soaked, for the hot weather has already
arrived and there is no fear of catching cold.
The Buddhist Lent
always comes in the Rainy Season
and to help them to endure the solemn period Burmese
Buddhists begin and end it with a great festival.
The full moon of Wa-Zo which usually falls in early
July marks the beginning of Wa or Lent and is a
holiday of several days' duration, in which the
Buddhist puts on his gayest clothes and goes to the
pagoda ; usually he will spend a few minutes in
prayer or meditation before an image of the Buddha ;
the rest of the day will be spent in seeing the
great bamboo and tinsel figures of nats or animals
which have been specially built for the occasion, in
visiting friends, in partaking of the lavish
hospitality provided by generous people, or at night
watching a performance of one of the great zats or
birth-stories of the Buddha.
The end of Lent is marked by the Thadin-gyut
festival which falls in late September or early
October, and is. ushered in by a great feasting of
the monks and an offering of presents. But the most
striking feature of this festival is the myriads of
small lanterns with which the monasteries, pagodas
and houses are illuminated at night, making an
inexpressibly beautiful effect. This Burmese Feast
of Lights has as its religious background the
commemoration of the Buddha's return from the Tawadeintha heaven when the devas lined his route
and illuminated the way.
The Buddhists find another occasion for festival in
the cremation of any monk of note who has died. The
monk does not die as an ordinary man does ; he
'returns' to the highest heaven of devas or perhaps
even to the immaterial regions of Nirvana. So his
funeral is called pon-gyi-byanthe return of the
great glory, and is an occasion for rejoicing. The
monk's body is preserved until an appropriate day
has been fixed for the funeral, and in the meantime
alms are collected to cover the considerable cost
involved. A miniature monastery in bamboo and paper
is built, in the centre of which is the funeral
pyre, a lofty platform crowned by a seven-roofed
spire, the whole erection towering to fifty or
sixty feet. The coffin is brought in procession,
placed on the platform, and then the pyre is lighted
by rockets fired from a distance. When the whole
frail erection has been burnt, the few pieces of
bones that remain are collected and buried somewhere
near the pagoda.
A high light in nearly all these festivals is the
performance of one of the great birth-stories of
the Buddha which tell the story of one of the
previous existences before he attained to Buddhahood.
There are ten of these great zats or Awes all of
which are well known to Buddhists, and inculcate the
ten great virtues to be cultivated by all who are
striving to reach Nirvana. These plays are very long
and take all night to perform. They are very like
the mystery plays of mediaeval times in Europe and
combine a good deal of broad humor as well as
religious teaching. Nowadays, however, the tendency
is to substitute modern plays which have not the
same religious interest as the old well-loved
birth-stories.
.
The Way Of Revival
It has often been said that with no definite belief
in -an Eternal God or an undying personality in man,
and with the consequent absence of any worship or
prayer, Buddhism is not a religion but a
philosophical and ethical system only. A study of
Buddhism in tends to confirm that criticism,
and the popular aberrations in connection with
spirit-worship offer further confirmation. Again the
tendency in to emphasize the metaphysical
arguments and analyses at the expense of the
beautiful moral teaching is disquieting to those
who claim Buddhism as a religion.
Buddhists claim that their religion is above all a
search for truth and that in its doctrine of
causation it anticipated the scientific method.
Certainly its robust assertion of the responsibility
of the individual for his present state is a healthy
rebuff to those who see in their difficulties and
trials no personal responsibility but simply the
caprice of God or fate. But is not its explanation
of suffering too simple and mechanistic ? The
problems of life are never easy, and the fact
remains that we are members one of another and that
many suffer through the ignorance, misjudgment or
criminal intent of one. Yet Buddhism does insist on
the operation of law in the spiritual and moral
spheres, and urges the individual to work out his
own salvation with diligence.
Inevitably, with the transition from the personal
presence of the founder of any religion to the
society formed to carry on his message and work,
there is a loss of power and understanding ; even
his wisest and most devoted disciples cannot have
the fullness of his spiritual genius and insight.
Some kind of organization is necessary so that his
gospel shall not be forgotten, but any
ecclesiastical system is bound to lose something of
the Teacher's freshness and originality. In times
when faith grows dim and practice lax the remedy is
to return to the study of the Founder, his mission
and teaching. This has been the secret of Christian
revivals, notably in the case of Francis of Assisi
and John Wesley, and this is the way to new life and
inspiration. A more devotional study of the Buddha
and his teaching, and its application to personal
and national life, would result in spiritual and
moral advance.
Burmese Buddhists are very naive in some of their
assertions, and in their trusting acceptance of
tradition. Some of them claim a superiority for
Buddhism because it has never been attacked by
modern criticism in the way that Christianity has.
This is only because the time has not yet come ;
with the development of education and scientific
thought the searchlight of criticism is bound to be
turned on the Buddhist Scriptures and traditions,
and by their own students. Those who are fearless
for truth, as Buddhists claim to be, should welcome
a courageous examination of tradition in the light
of higher and textual criticism, disregarding the
possible vested interests of Sangha or nationalism.
Let them get back to the historical Buddha, Gaudama
the man, to his original message to some extent
preserved in the Pitakas, to some extent covered up
by them. Let them not be afraid to study the
development of Buddhist thought in the Mahayana
tradition, for there too will be preserved fragments
of an original gospel. Let them not be afraid to
study the life and teaching of that other great
Blessed One, Jesus of Nazareth, for there is a
spiritual kinship between the Buddha and the Christ
which their followers have so far failed to
recognise. Somewhere in Buddhism there is a gospel,
good news for men in general, which has become
obscured in the centuries of tradition. Men need not
be afraid for the Truth ; it is always greater than
they are ; they need not tremble lest criticism
should weaken their religion—a true religion must be
strong enough to carry its adherents, and not the
other way round. And surely the result of such a
fearless attitude would be a heightening of the
spiritual stature of the Buddha, a deeper
appreciation of the power of his message, and a
putting into practice of the good life which he
lived and taught.
The Coming Buddha
Burmese Buddhists believe that there have been four
Buddhas, of whom Gaudama was the fourth. There is a
fifth and final Buddha still to come, Arimaddeyya or
:Maitreya. Gaudama Buddha himself foretold the
coming of this Kindly One, endowed with all wisdom
and righteousness ; he also stated that the
Buddhist religion as taught by himself would
flourish for 500 years and then decay. In the
Burmese text of the Scriptures this figure has been
amended to 5,000 years, and the same adaptation has
been made in Ceylon.
In this expectation of the final Buddha is not
very prominent, although in the inscriptions his
coming is regarded as the consummation of history ;
to behold it is the greatest desire of the devout,
to miss it is irretrievable disaster. A Shan monk
described the coming of Arimaddeyya in these words :
'As the last Buddha was the Lord of Wisdom, so the
next Buddha will be the Lord of Love. The mountains
will be levelled, and the world become a vast plain
full of orchards, gardens and rice-fields. Man then
will be without any enemy among men, and without
fear of ravening beasts. It will be the age of
plenty and good-will.' Strangely reminiscent of the
golden age longed for by the prophet Isaiah.
A deeper regard for this nearly forgotten article of
faith, and a new acceptance of the noble ethical
teaching of the Buddha, may make the new
nearer this ideal.
all at e-books |